Sunday, 20 May 2007

Keyboard conundrums

Take a look at our keyboards. Pretty aren't they? Well, I think so:
Notice how they curve upwards, towards the user? That's the problem - I wanted a flat-ish design with a movable flap underneath, like with the older G4 era design:





Why? Because having a keyboard flat with the surface of your desk is better for your hands. Having the keyboard tilt up towards you is a bit more stressful to the wrists. Go on, try it and see.

With a flat keyboard your wrists are more or less straight, but with a tilted one your wrists are bent upwards. Over time this can be uncomfortable. When I pointed this out to Steve he said, yeah, true, but the market wants curved keyboards - it looks more sophisticated. And besides it's cheaper to make - fewer parts to assemble, you see.

It's like a V6 engine vs. a straight six: the straight six is actually better (see BMW) but the reason why many car companies make V6s is that people think they're more advanced or some nonsense. You can't undo a V6 but at least with our older keyboards you could prop them up to make them flat again.

Just an example of the small compromises that we have to make.

No comments: